Serotonin 5-HT7 receptor (5-HT7R), one of the most recently discovered members of the serotonergic system, has become a promising target in the search for central nervous system disorders. Despite the number of preclinical results, none of the selective 5-HT7R agents has been approved; therefore, the clinical significance of this protein has not been confirmed yet. Recently, we described very promising, selective, and highly potent hydantoin-derived 5-HT7R antagonists with confirmed antidepressant activity in vivo and a very good ADMET profile; however, they have been tested in behavioral studies as racemates. In this work, the synthesis of optically pure hydantoin-derived 5-HT7R agents using cost-effective, classical methods has been presented for the first time. X-ray crystallographic analysis confirmed the absolute configuration on both stereogenic centers and allowed for the elucidation of the mechanism of introduction of epichlorohydrin into the hydantoin N3-position. The radioligand binding results showed a clear configuration preference for 5-HT7R affinity. The molecular modeling results further indicated the key interaction responsible for lower affinity (with amino acid I3 × 29). Finally, the comparison of the antidepressant and anxiolytic effects of racemates versus stereoisomers suggests an influence of additional, apart from the action on 5HT7R, factors responsible for the activity in vivo, which is worthy of deeper insight within further studies.