Vaccination against coliform mastitis has become part of mastitis control programs in the past 3 decades, as a means of reducing the severity of clinical mastitis. Our study objective was to evaluate the effect of 2 commercially available vaccines on clinical, behavioral, and antibody response following Escherichia coli intramammary challenge in cows near peak lactation. Cows (n = 12 per group) were vaccinated with vaccine 1 (V1) or vaccine 2 (V2) at dry-off, 21 d pre-calving, and 14 d post-calving. Twelve cows served as unvaccinated controls (CTL). Cows were challenged with E. coli in a rear quarter at approximately 100 d in milk. Milk samples were collected pre- and post-challenge to enumerate E. coli and determine somatic cell count. Serum was collected before each vaccination and at d 0, 1, 2, 3, 6, 30, and 60 relative to challenge, to study antibody response. Milk IgA and tumor necrosis factor-α concentrations were determined in whey. Vaginal temperature, cow activity, and milk yield and components were monitored post-challenge. Bacterial count, somatic cell score, milk yield and component decline, vaginal temperature, activity measures, and antibody and cytokine response were analyzed for treatment differences. The effects of parity, breed, and a repeated measure of time were also tested. Seven cows had to be removed from the study post-challenge for antibiotic treatment (CTL and V1, n = 3 each; V2, n = 1), 2 of which were euthanized (both CTL). Vaccinated cows exhibited fever (vaginal temperature ≥39.4°C) 3 h earlier than CTL cows, but we found no differences between treatments for bacterial count, somatic cell score, or milk yield reduction. Vaccinated cows spent more time lying per rest bout 2 d post-challenge, but total daily lying time was not different from CTL cows during the 7 d post-challenge. The vaccines differed in antibody response: V1 cows had greater serum IgG1 and IgG2 post-challenge. A parity effect was also evident: primiparous cows had lower bacterial counts, somatic cell score and a smaller milk yield decline than multiparous cows, but also had lower antibody production. Immunization with either J5 bacterin did not reduce clinical signs of mastitis in cows challenged at 100 d in milk, demonstrating that the effects of J5 vaccination had diminished at peak lactation.
