Melanogenesis is the biological process regulating the synthesis of melanin pigments in melanocytes. Defective melanogenesis is associated with numerous human skin diseases, including, but not limited to, albinism, vitiligo, melasma, and hypo- and hyperpigmentation disorders. Tyrosinase is the rate-limiting enzyme controlling melanogenesis, and hence tremendous efforts have been made to identify potent and safe inhibitors of tyrosinase function. However, despite decades of research, currently there is no effective treatment that inhibits melanogenesis or tyrosinase activity with no adverse side effects. In this study, we report the characterization of the ML233 chemical as a potent inhibitor of tyrosinase activity in vivo and in vitro. We demonstrate that ML233 reduces melanin production in the zebrafish model with no observable significant toxic side effects, and in murine melanoma cells. We also predict that these effects are mediated through direct tyrosinase-ML233 interaction, i.e., binding of the ML233 molecule to the active site of the protein to inhibit its function. Together, our results reveal that ML233 plays roles in both healthy and pathological skin cells via inhibition of melanin production. ML233-mediated tyrosinase inhibition is a potentially safe and effective approach to alleviate the symptoms of melanocyte-associated diseases and thereby substantially improve human health.