Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a chronic, systemic, and autoimmune disease characterized by inflammation and pain in the joints. While RA and TNF‐alpha inhibitors have historically been associated with an increased risk of lymphoma, chronic lymphocytic leukemia/small lymphocytic lymphoma (CLL/SLL) is infrequently seen. CD23 negative CLL is rare. Extranodal manifestations of CLL/SLL are uncommon. While cutaneous involvement is among the more common extranodal manifestations, leukemia cutis is rare. Furthermore, subcutaneous leukemia cutis as the initial manifestation CLL/SLL is exceedingly uncommon. We describe a patient with longstanding RA on chronic TNF‐alpha inhibition who presented with an isolated subcutaneous mass. Excisional biopsy demonstrated sheets of small, uniform, and mature lymphocytes with flow cytometric analysis noting a monoclonal B‐cell population negative for CD23 expression but positive for CD5, CD19, CD20, CD38, kappa light chain, and CD200 expression. Further immunostaining was negative for cyclin‐D1 and SOX11 and positive for CD43 and LEF1, overall consistent with CLL/SLL‐induced subcutaneous leukemia cutis. While treatments for CLL/SLL‐induced leukemia cutis vary, in this case, consolidative local radiation led to resolution of the remaining cutaneous lesion. Caution is advised when considering the use of TNF‐alpha inhibitors in patients with a history of lymphoma.