Connexins (Cxs) function as gap junction (GJ) channels and hemichannels that mediate intercellular and transmembrane signaling, respectively. Here, we investigated the proximal segment of the first extracellular loop, E1, of two closely related Cxs, Cx26 and Cx30, that share widespread expression in the cochlea. Computational studies of Cx26 proposed that this segment of E1 contains a parahelix and functions in gating. The sequence of the parahelix is identical between Cx26 and Cx30 except for an Ala/Glu difference at position 49. We show through cysteine-scanning and mutational analyses that position 49 is pore-lining and interacts with the adjacent Asp50 residue to impact hemichannel functionality. When both positions 49 and 50 are charged, as occurs naturally in Cx30, the hemichannel function is dampened. Co-expression of Cx30 with Cx26(D50N), the most common mutation associated with keratitis-ichthyosis-deafness syndrome, results in robust hemichannel currents indicating that position 49–50 interactions are relevant in heteromerically assembled hemichannels. Cysteine substitution at position 49 in either Cx26 or Cx30 results in tonic inhibition of hemichannels, both through disulfide formation and high-affinity metal coordination, suggestive of a flexible region of the pore that can narrow substantially. These effects are absent in GJ channels, which exhibit wild-type functionality. Examination of postnatal cochlear explants suggests that Cx30 expression is associated with reduced propagation of Ca2+ waves. Overall, these data identify a pore locus in E1 of Cx26 and Cx30 that impacts hemichannel functionality and provide new considerations for understanding the roles of these connexins in cochlear function.