We used site-directed mutagenesis to construct 55 single-site variants of rhPTH, a recombinantly-expressed form of human parathyroid hormone (1-34) containing three amino acid changes compared to the natural sequence (ML8, ML18 and FY34). We identified several mutations, at residues Lys(13), Glu(19), Val(21), Glu(22), Lys(27) and Asp(30), that increase biological activity by up to 2. 5-fold, as measured by stimulation of adenylate cyclase activity in rat UMR-106 cells. We constructed a series of 15 variants in which two to eight substitutions at these positions were combined, and found that the mutations behaved additively, leading to peptides with significantly enhanced potency. The most active combination variant, with six substitutions (KS13, ES19, VQ21, ES22, KQ27 and DN30), is 15 times more active than the parent molecule. However, the extent to which such combinations increase the activity of the peptide depends critically on the identity of the residues at positions 8 and 18. We constructed two of the combination variants in a variety of sequence backgrounds containing different combinations of leucine, methionine and norleucine at positions 8 and 18. Enhancements in potency were significantly reduced when Met or Nle was present at either of these positions, both in UMR-106 cells and human SaOS-2 cells. A corresponding non-additivity was observed in direct measurements of receptor binding affinity on UMR-106 cells. These results suggest that interactions, either direct or indirect, between certain PTH side chains prevent these mutations from behaving in an additive manner.