Resource recovery from municipal sewage sludge has traditionally emphasized bulk organics and macronutrients, whereas the potential recovery and utilization of other sludge-derived organic constituents as low-dose functional agricultural inputs remains insufficiently explored. Here, two alkaline thermal hydrolysis (ATH)-derived liquid products collected from independent full-scale municipal sludge-treatment facilities, ATH and F-ATH (a mechanical vapor recompression (MVR)-concentrated product obtained through a separate full-scale processing route), were characterized and evaluated in a greenhouse lettuce experiment combining reduced mineral fertilization with foliar application of the liquid products. F-ATH contained 57.80% total solids, 74.67 g/L total nitrogen, and 32.56 mg/mL free amino acids, compared with 3.13%, 2.81 g/L, and 2.45 mg/mL, respectively, in ATH. Targeted analysis identified 41 phytohormone-related analytes across the two products, while the measured heavy-metal concentrations were relatively low. In the greenhouse experiment, the combined F-ATH-50% treatment, involving a 50% reduction in mineral-fertilizer application, increased aboveground fresh biomass by 28.75%, whereas dry biomass increased by only 7.51%, while cumulative treatment-derived N input was 37.56% lower than in the full-fertilization control (CK). ATH-10% increased aboveground fresh biomass by 18.73%, although dry biomass decreased by 8.41% relative to CK. Physiological measurements, leaf phytohormone profiling, and widely targeted metabolomics revealed coordinated treatment-associated changes in antioxidant status, hormone homeostasis, and specialized metabolism. Integration of these datasets highlighted two prominent response domains involving tryptophan (TRP)/auxin-related and phenylalanine (Phe)/phenylpropanoid-related metabolism. Overall, these findings provide preliminary evidence for the potential use of ATH-derived liquid products within reduced-mineral-fertilization strategies and suggest a possible higher-value sludge-valorization pathway.