There are many benefits to early detection of prostate cancer, including improved survival rates, less invasive treatment options, and better quality of life. Apart from traditional tests and imaging (including the prostate-specific antigen (PSA) test, digital rectal exam, biopsy, computed tomography (CT), and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)), an imaging technique called prostate-specific membrane antigen positron emission tomography (PSMA PET) is more specific and sensitive, targeting PSMA expressed by prostate cancer cells on their surface. This case report describes a 62-year-old male with metastatic prostate adenocarcinoma and unusual PSMA uptake in the spleen. Elevated PSA levels and MRI indicated aggressive prostate cancer, confirmed by a Gleason score of 7 from biopsies. A PSMA PET/CT scan showed intense activity in both the prostate and spleen, initially suggesting metastasis. However, further imaging identified the splenic lesion as a benign hemangioma. This case showcases the importance of thorough diagnostic evaluations for distinguishing metastatic disease from benign conditions to ensure accurate diagnosis and appropriate treatment.